Reproductive Health-Care Providers Challenge Arizona Laws That Put Women’s Health at Risk

On Thursday, April 11, women’s reproductive health-care providers filed a federal lawsuit seeking to remove Arizona TRAP (Targeted Regulation of Abortion Providers) laws that prevent and delay many women from accessing abortion. The lawsuit was filed by reproductive health-care provider Planned Parenthood Arizona and individual clinicians represented by O’Melveny & Myers, Planned Parenthood Federation of America, the Center for Reproductive Rights, and Squire Patton Boggs.

Arizona’s extreme, medically unnecessary TRAP laws violate Arizona women’s constitutional right to access legal abortion. Their effect has been dramatic: a 40 percent decline in abortion clinics, leaving 80 percent of Arizona counties with no access to abortion clinics, and weeks-long waiting times for services. There is only one abortion provider in the northern part of the state, and that health center only provides medication abortion one day per week.

“Arizona lawmakers have made it difficult or even impossible for women to access safe, legal abortion,” said Bryan Howard, president and CEO of Planned Parenthood Arizona. “Medically unnecessary laws that only serve to attack women’s rights and put women’s health at risk should be overturned to protect women’s health and rights.”

The lawsuit challenges three aspects of Arizona’s TRAP laws:

  • an advanced practice clinician ban that prohibits qualified advanced practice clinicians like nurse practitioners from providing abortions and related services;
  • a mandatory delay and two-trip requirement that imposes needless barriers to health care, including requiring patients to visit clinics in person, twice, with a 24-hour mandatory delay between visits that, in practice, delays women far longer; and
  • a telemedicine ban that prevents access to early abortion services in remote areas.

“For too long, Arizona has burdened women with unnecessarily restrictive rules that are designed to make it harder to access constitutionally protected health care,” said Catalina Vergara, a partner at O’Melveny & Myers LLP. “O’Melveny is partnering with Planned Parenthood Arizona, the Center for Reproductive Rights, and individual clinicians to challenge these overly burdensome regulations. Through our lawsuit, we hope to advance and protect women’s right to safe and accessible reproductive health care.”

“I treat my patients based on science and evidence, and the science and evidence are clear — abortion is one of the safest medical procedures, and abortion care is part of the full spectrum of reproductive health care,” said Planned Parenthood Federation of America President Dr. Leana Wen. “When politicians restrict the right to safe, legal abortion, they are directly interfering with medical practice and endangering women’s lives. We in the medical and public health community know that to improve health, we must get rid of  these outdated, medically unnecessary restrictions.”

“Many parts of Arizona have become an abortion desert,” said Marc Hearron, senior counsel at the Center for Reproductive Rights. “These laws have no medical basis — their sole purpose is to make it much more difficult to obtain an abortion, and they have done just that. We are asking the court to strike down these laws as unconstitutional because they impose an undue burden on women seeking abortions.”

Medically unnecessary laws have essentially stripped abortion access from many women living in Navajo, Hopi, Hualapai, and Apache tribal jurisdictions, among others, as well as rural women in other regions of the state who already face many barriers to accessing essential health care.

Allowing qualified medical professionals to prescribe pills for abortion via telemedicine would expand access to women in underserved areas. Medication abortion has been available in the U.S. for many years and is extremely safe — the complication rate is less than 0.5 percent, according to the Guttmacher Institute, whether provided in-person or by telemedicine. Telemedicine has been widely embraced in Arizona and across the nation as a high-quality health-care option. In fact, the Legislature has promoted the use of telemedicine to provide other health-care services, including treatments for trauma, burns, cardiology, pulmonology, infectious diseases, and neurologic diseases — even strokes.

“I am qualified to provide medication abortion,” said Deanna Wright, NP, a nurse practitioner with Planned Parenthood Arizona. “I could safely provide medication abortion to women in underserved communities, but the state is stopping me.”

Permitting qualified clinicians to provide abortion services would also help expand access. Abortion is the only medical procedure that the Arizona Legislature has specifically banned trained nurse practitioners and physician assistants from providing, even though they can provide medically identical procedures in miscarriage management.

2 thoughts on “Reproductive Health-Care Providers Challenge Arizona Laws That Put Women’s Health at Risk

  1. Good Evening,
    I have been reading about the abortion crisis that’s rippling through America. How Alabama has completely legalized abortion unless it is absolutely necessary for a woman’s life. How they want to take it all the way to the Supreme Court to overthrow Roe V Wade. I am afraid my state, Arizona, will join their that motive soon enough. I am already registered to vote, and plan on doing so, but I want to know what else I can do to rally against this onslaught on women health and reproductive rights.
    Thank you,
    A Very Concerned Teenager

  2. Thank you for your comment. This has been a scary week, highlighting how profoundly these ripples from across the state. Unfortunately, these laws (or attempts to pass laws like Alabama and Georgia), exist in Arizona: banned public and private insurance coverage abortion; forced mandatory ultrasound on patients, and have systematically called for increased barriers to not only abortion, but birth control and medically accurate sex education. In fact, in the last decade alone, Arizona’s legislature has passed more than 30 restrictions on access to abortion health care based on ideology of harming people.

    Arizona ranks near the bottom in stats like mother & infant mortality and near the top of the list when it comes to the number of children living in poverty. These pro-life folks are only concerned with fetal life; there are no programs to identify families in crisis or in need of support as a way to minimize the impact on the foster care system. Families should have the resources to be safe and healthy; but there is a cadre of decision makers set on criminalizing bodies instead of protecting and promoting people.

    The sky in not falling! There is hope. There are other people like you who want to stand up and do more to protect the rights of everyone to build the life they want. Planned Parenthood has volunteers who register people to vote, table at events to talk to communities about the urgency of this fight, and canvass for issues like comprehensive sex education in schools.

    Education is a powerful. Stories stymie stigma. Civic engagement and advocacy can change the course of history. Remember, over 60% of Americans (and Arizona!) believe that abortion should remain legal, and it should be safe.

    We need more folks in the community talking about the need for everyone to be able to access the health care they need. We know that 1 in 4 people who get pregnant in their lifetime will have an abortion. Someone you love has had an abortion.

    We need you in this fight – please join us! For more information on how to become a volunteer, please complete the form at the end of this link (you may need to cut and paste into your browser)

    thank you

Comments are closed.